Scottish Sterling Silver Salver or Presentation Bowl, Edinburgh
Hollowware (Salver, Tray, or Shallow Bowl) · Unknown Edinburgh Silversmith (Maker's mark partially obscured/absent in focal area)
Pattern: Traditional Plain or Polished Pattern
Type
Hollowware (Salver, Tray, or Shallow Bowl)
Maker
Unknown Edinburgh Silversmith (Maker's mark partially obscured/absent in focal area)
Material
Sterling Silver (.925 purity)
Dimensions
Dimensions unknown from photo; weight estimated by gauge to be significant for hollowware (approx. 300-800 grams depending on diameter)
Description
A refined example of Scottish silver craftsmanship characterized by the distinct Edinburgh castle and thistle marks. The item features a wide, reflective surface intended to showcase the purity of the metal.
Key Features
Distinctive Scottish 'Thistle' purity mark and the three-towered Edinburgh castle town mark; presence of an incense/duty mark for tax compliance
Material & Composition
Sterling Silver (.925 purity)
Finish & Decoration
Polished mirror finish with visible age-related surface abrasions and fine scratches
Hallmarks & Stamps
Featured hallmarks include the Thistle (Scottish Sterling purity mark), the Castle (Edinburgh Assay Office mark), and a Duty Mark (Monarch's head, likely George III or IV)
Construction Details
Hand-raised or spun silver sheet construction with planished and polished surfaces
Functional Features
Flat or shallow utilitarian surface designed for service or display; possibly originally featured a footed base
Handle & Grip Details
None visible; typical of salvers or circular tray forms
Craftsmanship Details
High-quality punch striking; indicates a piece produced by a master silversmith compliant with the Incorporation of Goldsmiths of the City of Edinburgh
Authentication Indicators
Genuine struck hallmarks with characteristic 'displacement' of metal around the punch; authentic wear patterns and oxidation in the recesses of the stamps
Origin & Manufacturing
Edinburgh, Scotland; manufactured under strict guild regulations of the Scottish Assay Office
Era & Period
Late Georgian to Early Victorian (c. 1784–1840) based on the presence of the Duty Mark
Age Estimate
Circa 1810-1830 based on the crispness of the George III/IV duty mark and thistle style
Cultural Significance
Represents the high social status of Scottish silver ownership during the Enlightenment era and the Regency period
Condition Notes
Fair to Good. Heavy surface scratching ('spider-webbing') consistent with decades of improper cleaning or frequent use; no major dents visible in frame
Value Estimate
$400 - $1,200 USD depending on size, total weight, and identification of the specific silversmith
Care & Maintenance
Requires professional hand-polishing with a high-quality non-abrasive cream like Wright's Silver Cream; avoid machine buffing which can erase hallmarks
Similar Pieces
English London-made salvers of the same era (Leopard's head marks); Sheffield-made plated salvers (often with 'bleeding' copper)
Interesting Facts
The thistle mark was used in Edinburgh to signify sterling silver starting in 1759, replacing the previous assay master's initials